Halloween Would You Rather

Pile of Halloween would you rather question cards with text for Pinterest Pile of Halloween would you rather question cards with text for Pinterest Pile of Halloween would you rather question cards with text for Pinterest

Make Halloween a little more fun with these spooktacular Halloween would you rather questions! It’s a great way to learn more about friends and family as they choose whether they’d rather be a vampire or werewolf, eat a Snickers or Reese’s Peanut Butter cup, and more!

Purple and orange papers with Halloween themed would you rather questions on them

Virtual Halloween Game

This year is kind of a strange one where Halloween parties, trick or treating, and trunk or treats might be a thing of the past. And hopefully the future.

cool things to put on a bucket list

Kids school Halloween parties , parades, and pumpkin carving contests may be postponed to 2021. That doesn’t mean you can’t still have Halloween fun!

This Halloween would you rather game is one of the first in a series of virtual Halloween games I’m going to be sharing. This ghoulish recall Halloween memory game is the second!.

They’re perfect for playing together while physically distancing or on a virtual call with family and friends.

Or if you are in person, they’re great for that too!

Kids and adults will love this Halloween would you rather game because

  1. There’s no setup required other than a little printing and cutting.
  2. There are almost 50 different questions, which means you can pick and choose the ones you want to ask. Pick for your age group! If you need more, these
  3. Would You Rather is fun for all ages – kids, teens, adults, and seniors! All you need to be able to do is pick out of two options. So easy!


The beauty of this game is that you really don’t need anything other than the would you rather questions I’ve already made for you!

A row of purple Halloween would you rather question cards and a row of orange cards

Supply Notes

I’ve created printable cards that are pretty as well as a one-page document that lists out all of the questions if you just want to read them out to people, rather than cut and print.

There are two different designs of cards – orange and purple – there’s no difference between them, they all have different questions on them to choose from.

Looking for more Would You Rather games?

Get All The Games

How to Play

There are a number of different ways you can play Would You Rather. I’m going to explain the most basic of the games and if you want some more unique Halloween would you rather game ideas, check out these other would you rather questions with game instructions!

Print out and cut the would you rather question cards (or the full list).

Pick one of the questions and read it out loud to your group.

Ask one individual or the entire group to choose their answer, no explanation needed.

It’s as simple as that. I have two more fun versions of the game that turn this more into a party game with these Harry Potter would you rather questions here!

Game Tip!

If you’re playing with a large group, only have a few people answer each question instead of everyone! Or split into groups and have one person from each group answer the question to save time!

Halloween Would You Rather Questions

In case you just want some questions to ask, here’s the full list of questions!

  1. Be a real-life Vampire or Werewolf
  2. Watch Teen Wolf or An American Werewolf in London
  3. Be a black cat or a vampire bat
  4. Drink apple cider or eat pumpkin spice cake
  5. Eat candy corn or Smarties
  6. Be chased by Friday the 13th’s Jason or Halloween’s Michael
  7. Explore a corn maze or a haunted house
  8. Face a Zombie Apocalypse or an Invasion of 10-ft spiders
  9. Be locked in a room full of snakes or rats
  10. Dress up as a character from Harry Potter or Star Wars
  11. Live in Salem Massachusetts or Roswell New Mexico
  12. Take an evening swim at Amity Cove or a midnight stroll in a cemetery
  13. Listen to Edgar Allen Poe or Stephen King tell a scary store
  14. Be given a Snicker’s Bar or a Reese’s Peanut But cup
  15. Be forced to eat lobster brains or alligator hearts Fear Factor style
  16. Live a world where King Kong or Megalodon are real
  17. See Little Shop of Horrors or Sweeney Todd on Broadway
  18. Trick or Treat in a store-bought or homemade costume
  19. Watch a slasher film or get a root canal
  20. Wait for the Great Pumpkin with Linus or celebrate Christmas with Jack Skellington
  21. Have a nightmare featuring the clown Pennywise or the Headless Horseman
  22. Go to a Halloween party or watch game 7 of the World Series
  23. Be a member of the Brady Bunch or the Addams’ Family
  24. Have vampire teeth or a witch’s mole on your nose
  25. Never celebrate Halloween or Thanksgiving again
  26. Put “I’ll Be Back” or “I Told You I Was Sick” on your gravestone
  27. Eat a caramel apple or a caramel popcorn ball
  28. Listen to the song Monster Mash on repeat or Werewolves of London
  29. Visit Munich’s Oktoberfest or London’s Guy Fawkes Night
  30. Light a bonfire or a candle at the graves of the dead
  31. Frequently use the word “brilliant” or “clever”
  32. Eat pumpkin pie or apple cider donuts
  33. Stay at the Hotel Transylvania or the Monster House
  34. Ride the Tower of Terror or the Haunted Mansion
  35. Watch Beetlejuice or Ghostbusters
  36. See a UFO or Bigfoot
  37. Carve a jack-o-lantern or play some pranks
  38. Live in the world of A Quiet Place or Hocus Pocus
  39. Create a monster like Frankenstein or become one like Dr Jekyll
  40. Eat a live cockroach or play a game of Ouija
  41. Attend a sexy Halloween party or visit New England for the Autumn leaves
  42. Eat Extreme Sour Warheads or Hot Tamales
  43. Be scared or scare someone
  44. Fall into a pool of blood or kiss the creature from the Black Lagoon
  45. Watch Hitchcock’s Psycho or Spielberg’s Poltergeist
  46. Compete on the Masked Singer or Fear Factor
  47. Stay home to give out candy or go trick-or-treating
  48. Watch a show by Houdini or Siegfried and Roy

Looking for more Fun Halloween Games?


Game FAQs

How many people can play Would You Rather?

You can play Would You Rather with one person, two people, five people, ten people, or an entire office or class. With large groups, I recommend just picking a couple of people to answer each question rather than everyone.

best song to run to
What are the Would You Rather cards for?

I like to cut the cards out, place them around a party, and let people ask each other as they go. Or just have a deck of question cards that you pull one out of to ask the group.

Are there any more Would You Rather questions?

Yes! I have tons of other Would You Rather questions here! If you want specific themed questions, these Disney would you rather questions and these Marvel ones are fun!

A hand holding an orange Halloween would you rather question card with witches and spiderwebs

More Halloween Games

Download the Printable

Enter your first name and email address in the form below to get the printable Halloween Would You Rather questions. You will receive a link to download the PDF to your email within minutes.

Or if you’d prefer to not provide your email, you can purchase a copy of the cards in my shop here .

If you do not see it, make sure to check your promotions, spam, and junk folders!

If you cannot see a form below, click here to get to it .